How well can we really know someone else? It's a deceptively simple question, but one that becomes far more complicated when that someone is the person you've sworn to love for the rest of your life. In her new film 'Gentle Monster', director Marie Kreutzer ('Corsage') explores the murky territory of marriage, betrayal and the stories we tell ourselves about the people closest to us, even if they're not always the truth, crafting a domestic drama that is equal parts compelling and frustratingly elusive.
At the centre is Léa Seydoux ('Dune: Part Two'), delivering what is comfortably an instant hall-of-fame performance as Lucy, a Munich-based concert pianist who uproots her life to the German countryside in support of her husband Phillip's (Laurence Rupp, TV's 'Unfamiliar') flailing mental health. Their new, idyllic life with their 9-year-old son Johnny (Malo Blanchet) soon unravels when the police show up at their door and confiscate Phillip's computers and hard drives. He appears unfazed but gives no answers to either the police or his wife; Lucy is stunned. As the accusations against Phillip come to light, Lucy is left to navigate an increasingly destabilising and horrifying new reality, caught between the person she thought she married and the danger of who he possibly is.
'GENTLE MONSTER' TRAILER
Seydoux handles the gravity of Lucy's predicament in a manner that is nothing short of extraordinary. She delivers a masterclass in restraint, communicating an unbearable amount of pain through the smallest changes in her facial expression, an uncomfortable silence or a particularly agonising glance. The key emotional pull of 'Gentle Monster' lies in the tension of watching Lucy attempt to maintain some semblance of normality while the foundations of her entire existence crumble around her, and watching how her emotions come out in the pop songs she chooses to perform professionally ('Would I Lie To You?' by Charles & Eddie is a key musical piece). Despite Lucy's initially headstrong demeanour, Seydoux captures the paralysis of a woman who doesn't know what to believe, what she's entitled to question or whether she can even trust her own instincts. It's a devastating piece of work, and frankly, a performance deserving of a considerably more satisfying script.
Ultimately, this is where my frustrations with 'Gentle Monster' begin.
Out of respect for real-life victims and given these crimes are of a very delicate nature, I've been quite vague in explaining the crux of Phillip's alleged behaviour in the film; this is also ironic, given that 'Gentle Monster' is far too vague for its own good. For a while, it does work to the film's advantage, as the deliberate withholding of information and the cyclical nature of Lucy's shock mirror her husband's constant stream of half-truths. Just as Lucy can't get a straight answer, neither can we. Kreutzer is clearly attempting to capture the psychological toll of one's reality hinging - and shifting - on the words of someone else, and there's merit in refusing to offer audiences the neat explanations we are so often accustomed to receiving.
Seydoux handles the gravity of Lucy's predicament in a manner that is nothing short of extraordinary. She delivers a masterclass in restraint, communicating an unbearable amount of pain through the smallest changes in her facial expression, an uncomfortable silence or a particularly agonising glance.
But there's a difference between deliberate ambiguity and simply not going anywhere. For such an intriguing hook, 'Gentle Monster' feels frustratingly stagnant, repeatedly circling the same emotional territory without properly interrogating the issue with the depth it deserves. Additionally, 'Gentle Monster' will be experienced by many audiences hot on the heels of 'Primetime', a much buzzier look at the same subject matter. However, while 'Primetime' was more concerned with the ethics of people exploiting crimes for entertainment/altruistic purposes, 'Gentle Monster's' focuses on how the crimes affect those who had no idea they were happening under their own noses. Considering her own personal experience with the subject, which caused a number of controversies around her last film 'Corsage', I found myself increasingly keen for Kreutzer to get her hands dirty, to push beyond the initial shock and explore more complicated questions of complicity, denial, and the people we choose to protect. Instead, the screenplay too often gestures toward these ideas before retreating into another prolonged moment of uncertainty.
The subplot involving Elsa (Jella Haase, TV's 'Kleo'), the police officer investigating Phillip who is facing her own personal crisis, doesn't help matters either. Clearly intended to provide another perspective on the crisis and to further highlight the invisible, emotional labour the bad behaviour of men bestows on the women around them, it feels awkwardly shoehorned into the narrative, pulling focus from the most absorbing element of the film: the slow-motion collapse of Lucy's family. While I'm not suggesting the diversions to Elsa are cop-outs for a messier exploration, they certainly feel like them.
Unsurprisingly, 'Gentle Monster' left me with conflicting feelings given the film's subject matter, but not in the way I was hoping. On one hand, I was completely captivated by Seydoux, whose performance alone makes the film worth seeking out; on the other, I couldn't shake the feeling that there is a far more provocative, challenging and genuinely devastating story buried beneath the narrative detours, something more than just an invitation to sit with the discomfort. Sometimes, the saddest part of it all is not knowing.