Deprecated: strtolower(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home3/makethes/domains/maketheswitch.com.au/public_html/articleamp.php on line 38
It Ends with Us Review: Colleen Hoover’s best-seller goes to the big screen | SWITCH.

IT ENDS WITH US

★★★

COLLEEN HOOVER’S BEST-SELLER GOES TO THE BIG SCREEN

THEATRICAL REVIEW
By Chris Dos Santos
8th August 2024

It may seem wild to hear, but Colleen Hoover's novel 'It Ends with Us' was originally published in 2016. Three years later the book crossed one million worldwide sales, but it wasn't until 2021 when BookTok took over everyone's feeds on TikTok that it truly exploded in popularity. In 2023, seven years after its original release, it was the best-selling novel of the year. 'It Ends with Us' has over one billion tags on TikTok; the power of the app not only bringing massive success for Hoover but also reigniting people's passion for reading. With all of this success, it's no surprise that 'It Ends with Us' is heading the big screen.

The film follows Lily Bloom (Blake Lively, 'A Simple Favour', 'The Shallows') moving to Boston after the death of her father (Kevin McKidd, TV's 'Grey's Anatomy'). She has plans to her open her dream flower shop, Lily Blooms, but she meets Ryle (Justin Baldoni, also the film's director, TV's 'Jane the Virgin'). Ryle pursues Lily but she is looking for a relationship but he is the type that usually goes for something more casual. When she was younger, she had a relationship with a homeless boy, Atlas (Brandon Sklenar, Paramount+'s '1923'), who she hasn't seen since an incident between Atlas and her dad. She runs into him again after years apart, and all those old emotions come flooding back. As her relationship with Ryle grows, she begins to be reminded of her mum (Amy Morton, TV's 'Chicago Fire') and dad's relationship and fears for her future.

SWITCH: 'IT ENDS WITH US' TRAILER

Heading into 'It Ends with Us' and knowing its subject matter, I had concerns over how this was going to play out. The story deals with domestic abuse. We have seen time and time again heavy subject matters played for cheap melodrama, especially in the romance genre. 'It Ends with Us' is extremely tasteful with how it handles the subject of abuse. This is largely attributed to Blake Lively; her performance here is extremely captivating. She drew me in and I was with her the entire time. The framing is also very solid - what could have been a "who will she choose? The abuser or the childhood crush?" plot instead chooses to focus on Lily and her journey. It's never framed as a love triangle and the tension is based on will she get out of this toxic relationship and not who will she end up with.

The problem, however, is the structure. There is a lot of ground to cover: we have to learn about Lily's childhood relationship with Atlas and her parents' issues. We also have to see Ryle go from charming to abusive while also seeing her flower shop open and have a friendship with Ryle's sister, Allysa (Jenny Slate, 'The Bob's Burgers Movie', 'Marcel the Shell with Shoes On'). Because there is so much groundwork, the third act suffers and is very rushed. Atlas also gets thrown to the sidelines and seems to be here because this is mainstream romance film and we need to have some positive hope that Lily will find love again. The book apparently has a journal from when Lily was a teenager that she finds and is reading - which is why flashbacks are happening - but the film does not. Flashbacks just happen sporadically and don't have a natural flow in the story.

The problem is the structure. There is a lot of ground to cover. Because there is so much groundwork, the third act suffers and is very rushed.

The oddest choice for me is Justin Baldoni, once again directing a romantic drama, but this time around cast himself as the abusive boyfriend. It seems strange to me to cast yourself in such a role. Compared to 'Five Feet Apart' and 'Clouds', this is a much more polished directorial effort, but still nothing exceptional.

'It Ends with Us' is sure to appeal to those BookTok fans. It's a surprisingly respectful and emotional story that is decently executed. Lively is carrying the film and completely draws you in. It suffers from structural problems and they make the final product weaker, but I do think its core demographic will get what they want out of this.

RELATEDTHE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE WAR OF THE ROHIRRIMA new anime masterpiece
RELATEDKRAVEN THE HUNTERVillains aren't born, they're made
RELATEDEND OF THE CENTURYThe exquisite beauty of love that could have been
RELATEDTHE BRUTALISTAn exhausting, frustrating monolith
RELATEDGLADIATOR IIA frustrating sequel lacking in immediacy or romanticism
RELATEDAKIRAStaring into the heart of a groundbreaking anime masterpiece
© 2011 - 2024 midnightproductions
All rights reserved

Support SWITCH | Disclaimer | Contact Us