Keep up-to-date on your favourite artists and movies, track gig and release dates, and join in the conversation.
Want more? Listen to our discussion of 'Goodbye Christopher Robin' on SWITCHCast
The Korean Film Festival in Australia is underway - make sure you click here to check out our reviews from this year's line-up!x
review, Goodbye Christopher Robin, Goodbye, Christopher, Robin, film, movie, latest movies, new movie, movie ratings, current movie reviews, latest films, recent movies, current movies, movie critics, new movie reviews, latest movie reviews, latest movies out, the latest movies, review film, latest cinema releases, Australian reviews, cinema, cinema reviews, Domhnall Gleeson, Margot Robbie, Kelly Macdonald, Will Tilston, Stephen Campbell Moore, Alex Lawther, Richard McCabe, Nico Mirallegro, Geraldine Somerville, Phoebe Waller-Bridge, Simon Curtis, Biography, Drama, History film rating




By Daniel Lammin
22nd November 2017

The stories of Winnie-the-Pooh and his friends in the Hundred Acre Wood are amongst the foundation stones of children’s literature. Written in the 1920s by British playwright A.A. Milne, they were inspired by his son Christopher and his collection of toys, and became an instant international success, thrusting Milne and his family into the spotlight. The repercussions of this become the basis for ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’, the latest biopic from director Simon Curtis.

Alan Milne (Domhnall Gleeson) returns from the First World War a shaken man, and in an attempt to find some peace, he relocates his wife Daphne (Margot Robbie), his young son Christopher, who they call Billy Moon (Will Tilston), and Billy’s nurse Olive (Kelly Macdonald) to the countryside. The relationship between the couple and their son are consistently estranged, but Alan and Billy find a connection by playing in the nearby woods with Billy’s collection of toys, and from their games emerges the Winnie-the-Pooh stories. However, rather than making Alan a celebrity, the books make Billy one instead, and that precious moment between father and son begins to shatter as the rest of the world begins to take ownership over Billy’s childhood.

The problem with most biopics of the last few years has been that the stories they try to tell just aren’t detailed or interesting enough to warrant cinematic dramatisation. In the case of ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’ though, it turns out to be the opposite. As a piece of material, the story of Alan and Billy offers an affecting narrative with complex character relationships, and asks genuine questions about the nature of childhood, the relationship between parents and children, and the cost that comes with artistic expression. Like ‘Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland’ and ‘Peter Pan’, Winnie-the-Pooh had an enormous and detrimental impact on the life of the child that inspired it, and this lends the narrative a lot more weight than the usual literary biopic.


The film itself just isn’t anywhere near as good as the story it’s telling. The screenplay from Frank Cottrell Boyce and Simon Vaughan has moments of sharpness and punch, but mostly relies on emotional clichés, all the more frustrating when the material doesn’t support them. Curtis’ direction is messy and unfocused, so that when the film finds its footing at points, it very soon starts to slip again. There’s no consistency in the visual language, imaginative or creative flairs grating against the hand-held documentary immediacy of the rest of the film. The editing denies the film of a consistent rhythm, making it feel longer than it actually is, and the cinematography suffers from the lack of directorial focus. ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’ moves too fast or too slow where it shouldn’t, misses the emotional punches it can’t afford to, and when it stumbles into the darker material, quickly jumps away as if to protect it from being too heavy for the casual audience it clearly wants to attract.

The performances don’t suffer too dramatically, with Gleeson, Tilston and Macdonald giving strong performances. Unfortunately, neither the screenwriters nor director seem to know how to handle Daphne, alternating between making her the loving mother and antagonist without any rhythm or reason. As such, Margot Robbie’s performance also feels pulled in all directions, making it hard to know how to connect with her. This is hardly Robbie’s fault though, as it is obvious no one knows what purpose Daphne is supposed to serve in the narrative in the first place.

The film itself just isn’t anywhere near as good as the story it’s telling.

That said, there was still something about ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’ that haunted me. There’s a palpable sense of melancholy throughout the film (helped by Carter Burwell’s excellent score), and amongst the mess are moments of astute observation that sting you in the right way. It could have been darker, but it still does more than most generic biopics would, and its emotional restraint prevent it from employing the kind of emotional blackmail that made films like ‘Finding Neverland’ (2004) or ‘The Danish Girl’ (2015) so turgid. I also find the stories of these children that inspired the great classics of children’s literature fascinating and very moving, so I may have already been predisposed to connect with the story the film was trying to tell.

Ultimately, ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’ never leaves the impression it clearly intends to, mostly because it doesn’t seem to know exactly what kind of impression it wants to leave in the first place. While this isn’t the best version of this story we could have gotten, it probably isn’t the worst. At least the moving and heartbreaking story behind the literary classic is able to somehow rise above the lacklustre filmmaking, enough that it kept me engaged for the length of the film. It’s a pity though, because stronger and more imaginative filmmakers could have made this something really special. Instead, while certainly not the kind Wikipedia biopic we get most of the time, ‘Goodbye Christopher Robin’ is still a sorely missed opportunity.

RELEASE DATE: 23/11/2017
RUN TIME: 1h 47m
CAST: Domhnall Gleeson
Margot Robbie
Kelly Macdonald
Will Tilston
Stephen Campbell Moore
Alex Lawther
Richard McCabe
Nico Mirallegro
Geraldine Somerville
Phoebe Waller-Bridge
DIRECTOR: Simon Curtis
PRODUCER: Damian Jones
Ride Like a Girl - Michelle Payne's Melbourne Cup win rides onto the big screen
TRENDINGWIN RIDE LIKE A GIRLMichelle Payne's Melbourne Cup win rides onto the big screen
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark - Terrifying tales come to life
Backtrack Boys - Heart-rending and inspiring
TRENDINGBACKTRACK BOYSHeart-rending and inspiring
Dreamland - Surrealist noir
Dora and the Lost City of Gold - Dora meets Indiana Jones (and a song about poop)
TRENDINGDORA AND THE LOST CITY OF GOLDDora meets Indiana Jones (and a song about poop)
Braid - A dark and unhinged fairytale
TRENDINGBRAIDA dark and unhinged fairytale
Downton Abbey - Transition from TV to film not as classy as expected
TRENDINGDOWNTON ABBEYTransition from TV to film not as classy as expected
Sydney Underground Film Festival 2019 - The reviews
Animals - Hedonistic female friendship and the art of growing up
TRENDINGANIMALSHedonistic female friendship and the art of growing up
Good Boys - More than just a young 'Superbad'
TRENDINGGOOD BOYSMore than just a young 'Superbad'
Top End Wedding - Outback fantastic
Judy & Punch - A dark fairytale from a fresh Australian voice
TRENDINGJUDY & PUNCHA dark fairytale from a fresh Australian voice
The Angry Birds Movie 2 - Flying a little bit higher the second time around
TRENDINGTHE ANGRY BIRDS MOVIE 2Flying a little bit higher the second time around
Granny Poetry Club - Growing old, friendship, learning and poetry
TRENDINGGRANNY POETRY CLUBGrowing old, friendship, learning and poetry
And Then We Danced - A passionate and remarkable classic in the making
TRENDINGAND THEN WE DANCEDA passionate and remarkable classic in the making
The Keeper - The true story of the Nazi goalkeeper and the English girl
TRENDINGTHE KEEPERThe true story of the Nazi goalkeeper and the English girl
Danger Close: The Battle of Long Tan - Close to home
The Wandering Chef - A delicious tale of human connection
TRENDINGTHE WANDERING CHEFA delicious tale of human connection
Freaks - Slow-burn science-fiction drama
TRENDINGFREAKSSlow-burn science-fiction drama
It Chapter 2 - The ambitious conclusion to the beloved horror epic
TRENDINGIT CHAPTER 2The ambitious conclusion to the beloved horror epic
© 2011 - 2019 midnightproductions
All rights reserved

Support SWITCH | Disclaimer | Contact Us