Keep up-to-date on your favourite artists and movies, track gig and release dates, and join in the conversation.
SEARCH RESULTS FOR
Click here for a Sydney Film Festival sneak peek with Festival Director Nashen Moodley!x
review, Motherless Brooklyn, Motherless, Brooklyn, film, movie, latest movies, new movie, movie ratings, current movie reviews, latest films, recent movies, current movies, movie critics, new movie reviews, latest movie reviews, latest movies out, the latest movies, review film, latest cinema releases, Australian reviews, cinema, cinema reviews, Bruce Willis, Edward Norton, Willem Dafoe, Leslie Mann, Ethan Suplee, Alec Baldwin, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, Josh Pais, Michael Kenneth Williams, Cherry Jones, Edward Norton, Crime, Drama film rating

MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN

★★★

A NEO-NOIR SET IN 1950s NEW YORK

THEATRICAL REVIEW
LATEST REVIEWS
By Joel Kalkopf
27th January 2020

Trench coats, cigarettes, fire escapes, jazz, shadowy figures - there's no mistaking that 'Motherless Brooklyn' is a good old-fashioned neo-noir. If there is a movie released this decade that uses the word "gumshoe" more regularly, I'll eat my fedora. Set in 1957 New York, Edward Norton's sophomore directorial feature follows Lionel Essrog (Edward Norton, 'Fight Club', 'American History X'), a private detective afflicted with Tourette's and OCD, as he tries to solve the murder of his mentor and friend, Frank (Bruce Willis, 'Die Hard'). As the case begins to unfold before him, Lionel unravels closely-guarded secrets that could not only determine the fate of New York, but maybe even put his own life at risk.

Norton has spoken frequently about how the novel of the same name, released 20 years ago by Jonathan Lethem, instantly captured his attention and how he's been obsessed with getting this to screen ever since. And it's easy to see why he was so drawn to Lionel as a protagonist. He's likeable but he's no great lead detective in the mould of Sam Spade or Sherlock Holmes; rather, he's simply a great asset to the team in the way that he remembers every conversation he's ever had or every setting he's ever been in. It is not that he is successful in his field despite his afflictions, but because of them. And herein lies this film's greatest challenge, and one it fails to overcome.

'MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN' TRAILER

Many actors have portrayed people with disabilities from all walks of life, and so many of them have won awards for it. Norton is equally as fantastic in this role, but the question has to be asked: what is the purpose? It's labelled as an affliction, nobody understands him because of his problems, but he seemingly gets by just fine, and suffers no real hurdles in the process. The people that he interrogates understand very quickly that he has a problem, and make no further comments. They do not treat him any differently than they would a regular detective, but perhaps even more importantly, it doesn't advance the plot or act as a clever character device - it's just there. That's not to say that he should be treated any differently, but then why create the illusion of an obstruction?

Similarly, it's confusing for an audience to simultaneously be told to laugh at something, and at the same time be told to sympathise with it. Norton tries to bring some comedy and lightheartedness to this otherwise brooding tale, with his manner of turning phrases and spinning people's words often entertaining - but then he also tries to highlight the struggles of his syndrome and the pain it can cause. Can you have your cake and eat it too? It makes the viewer uncomfortable and leaves them not knowing whether to laugh or not.

That being said, there is enough to like about this film. Thom Yorke continues to put his hand up as the go-to musician in the industry, with composer Daniel Pemberton's blues score hitting all the right notes. The aesthetic is everything reminiscent of the classic noir genre, and from the gin-soaked jazz clubs to the slums of Brooklyn, the old cliché that "the city plays as another character" rings true. When it comes to the acting, Norton parades that he barely paid anyone a cent, counting on people doing it for the love of the script - and he is rewarded for casting actors he trusts. Alec Baldwin ('Glengarry Glen Ross') brings the right amount of nuance as the film's antagonist Moses Randolph (loosely based off American tycoon Robert Moses), Willem Dafoe ('The Florida Project') is alluring, Gugu Mbatha-Raw ('Belle') adds much-needed warmth to the setting, and there are equally great cameos from Broadway star Cherry Jones, Leslie Mann ('Knocked Up', 'Blockers'), and Bobby Cannavale ('The Irishman'). The dynamic of the investigation team, once led by Frank (Willis), is great to watch, and in fact, the film could have done with more of it. After a great opening sequence, audiences are introduced the rest of the team, but it's a shame they are not really seen thereafter.

The aesthetic is everything reminiscent of the classic noir genre, and from the gin-soaked jazz clubs to the slums of Brooklyn, the old cliché that "the city plays as another character" rings true.

It's a difficult task to pace a noir for a modern audience, and you can feel the two and a half hour runtime. The story is interesting and the parallels to America in the present day are welcomed, but there isn't enough tonal balance to contrast all the shadowy moodiness. The plot is on the more convoluted side, and you'd imagine that with it being a story about following a trail of clues, 'Motherless Brooklyn' would reward repeat viewings - but I'm not sure I would optionally sit through all of it again. There is nothing inherently wrong with this film, bar some odd edits and framing choices, and Norton tackles the material fairly well, creating a great tribute to the noir era of filmmaking. It sometimes treads the line of parody rather than homage, but for anyone in the mood for crime mystery in the vein of 'Chinatown' or 'L.A. Confidential', this will absolutely hit the spot.

FAST FACTS
RELEASE DATE: 27/02/2020
CAST: Bruce Willis
Edward Norton
Willem Dafoe
Leslie Mann
Ethan Suplee
Alec Baldwin
Gugu Mbatha-Raw
Josh Pais
Michael Kenneth Williams
Cherry Jones
DIRECTOR: Edward Norton
TOP-RATED REVIEWS
Pocahontas - 25 years later, the colours of the wind are fading
TRENDINGPOCAHONTAS25 years later, the colours of the wind are fading
Heroic Losers - Enjoyable working-class heist hijinks from Argentina
TRENDINGHEROIC LOSERSEnjoyable working-class heist hijinks from Argentina
In The Heights - A dazzling screen adaptation of the modern musical classic
TRENDINGIN THE HEIGHTSA dazzling screen adaptation of the modern musical classic
The Violin Player - Sex and strings
TRENDINGTHE VIOLIN PLAYERSex and strings
Cosmic Sin - A film that delivers on the promise of its title
TRENDINGCOSMIC SINA film that delivers on the promise of its title
Sydney Film Festival 2021 - Festival Director Nashen Moodley reveals teaser films
TRENDINGSYDNEY FILM FESTIVAL 2021Festival Director Nashen Moodley reveals teaser films
It Must Be Heaven - A lyrical and absurdist trip around the world
TRENDINGIT MUST BE HEAVENA lyrical and absurdist trip around the world
King Otto - The world plans, and the Greek gods laugh
TRENDINGKING OTTOThe world plans, and the Greek gods laugh
The Perfect Secret - Seven friends with alcohol and secrets - let the games begin!
TRENDINGTHE PERFECT SECRETSeven friends with alcohol and secrets - let the games begin!
Revisiting 'Dark City' 20 years later - The most underrated and influential sci-fi film ever?
TRENDINGREVISITING 'DARK CITY' 20 YEARS LATERThe most underrated and influential sci-fi film ever?
Wet Woman in the Wind - A sexy struggle for conquest
TRENDINGWET WOMAN IN THE WINDA sexy struggle for conquest
Lion - A raw and powerful journey of identity
TRENDINGLIONA raw and powerful journey of identity
The Void - Filled with gory, stylish horror
TRENDINGTHE VOIDFilled with gory, stylish horror
Jumbo - The ups and downs of an unconventional romance
TRENDINGJUMBOThe ups and downs of an unconventional romance
Asia - Israel's award-winning drama
TRENDINGASIAIsrael's award-winning drama
Golden Voices - Immigration struggles with amusing challenges
TRENDINGGOLDEN VOICESImmigration struggles with amusing challenges
The Odd Family: Zombie on Sale - An extremely silly zomedy
TRENDINGTHE ODD FAMILY: ZOMBIE ON SALEAn extremely silly zomedy
The Land Before Time - 30th anniversary of a breathtaking animated masterpiece
TRENDINGTHE LAND BEFORE TIME30th anniversary of a breathtaking animated masterpiece
xXx: Return Of Xander Cage - The good, the bad and the ugly
TRENDINGxXx: RETURN OF XANDER CAGEThe good, the bad and the ugly
© 2011 - 2021 midnightproductions
All rights reserved

Support SWITCH | Disclaimer | Contact Us!