Keep up-to-date on your favourite artists and movies, track gig and release dates, and join in the conversation.
Want more? Listen to our discussion of 'Annabelle: Creation' on SWITCHCast
With this year's Jewish International Festival underway, SWITCH has checked out the program - click here to read our reviews.x
review, Annabelle: Creation, Annabelle:, Creation, film, movie, latest movies, new movie, movie ratings, current movie reviews, latest films, recent movies, current movies, movie critics, new movie reviews, latest movie reviews, latest movies out, the latest movies, review film, latest cinema releases, Australian reviews, cinema, cinema reviews, Stephanie Sigman, Talitha Bateman, Lulu Wilson, Philippa Ane Coulthard, Grace Fulton, Lou Lou Safran, Samara Lee, Tayler Buck, Anthony Lapaglia, Miranda Otto, David F. Sandberg, Horror, Mystery, Thriller film rating




By Daniel Lammin
10th August 2017

I’ve said many times in my reviews: horror franchises don’t work. More often than not, they descend into derivative repeats of whatever made the first instalment so successful, offering little more for audiences than the cinematic equivalent of a cheap haunted house at a crappy local fair. ‘The Conjuring’ franchise has somehow managed to both break this rule and prove it at the same time. The two main films, both directed with exceptional skill by James Wan, are rare examples of great studio horror films of late and a strong studio-led horror franchise. Concurrent to those though are its spin-offs, attempts to turn the Conjuring films into a kind of cinematic universe, mostly involving their most iconic creatures. And their success rate has so far left a lot to be desired.

The second spin-off ‘Annabelle: Creation’ is a prequel to the first 2014 spin-off ‘Annabelle’, which was itself a kind of prequel to the first 'Conjuring' film. (Because sure, why not?) This new film delves right back to the creation of Annabelle, the demonic doll who acts as host to some satanic evil. Set in the 50s, ‘Annabelle: Creation’ follows a small group of orphaned girls and their carer, Sister Charlotte (Stephanie Sigman), starting a new life at the isolated home of retired toymaker Samuel Mullins (Anthony LaPaglia) and his reclusive wife Esther (Miranda Otto). Janice (Talitha Bateman), one of the girls who suffers from the effects of polio, is drawn to a locked bedroom in the house, where she uncovers the doll Annabelle and lets free the evil locked away inside her, somehow connected to the Mullins’ deceased daughter.


The first ‘Annabelle’ film was a thundering bore, but early positive responses had me quite hopeful for this one, especially after the wonderful surprise of ‘Ouija: Origin of Evil’ last year. Unfortunately, while this new film has a lot more going for it than the first, it still leaves a hell of a lot to be desired. Despite its potentially interesting set-up and a few flashy set-pieces, so much of this film feels tired, familiar and annoyingly derivative. The first problem is the conceit of Annabelle herself - she worked as a figure of fear in the first 'Conjuring' film because we only saw her fleetingly. Essentially though, she’s just an inanimate object with a creepy face, and this film relies too much on the assumption that audiences will just be freaked out by the sight of her. She doesn’t actually do anything, she’s just an object for some kind of evil to hang onto, in this case a demon that look like the blown-up version of the Cornish pixies from ‘Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets’ but without Emma Watson to make it go away. There’s almost no attempt at originality with this "evil presence" (it literally says "For your soul" at one point in a deep gravelly voice, for goodness sake), and even though director David F. Sandberg pulls off some nice scary moments and some very flashy camera tricks, they’re almost entirely reaction shots, menacing music and close-ups of the bloody doll.

The film also relies too heavily on familiar horror tropes, referencing countless other (and better) horror films with visual nods that it thinks of as homage but just feel like laziness, giving you the impression that you’ve seen all this before. In a roundabout way, it does provide some unexpected satisfaction, allowing you to play a game where you predict what will happen/be said next with the satisfying guarantee that you’ll probably always be right. I’m never one for rolling my eyes when a character does something a bit dumb in a horror film (it's a convention of the genre, and can sometimes be very effective), but the level to which these characters keep making really stupid decisions, putting themselves in danger even when they know something bad is going on is unintentionally hilarious. You’ve never seen so many horrified reaction shots to doors in your life.

Essentially though, she’s just an inanimate object with a creepy face, and this film relies too much on the assumption that audiences will just be freaked out by the sight of her.

The saving grace of the film is the girls, especially Talitha Bateman as Janice and Lulu Wilson as Linda. The two have a lovely chemistry, and their affection for one another holds the film together mostly. There is something nice about having a majority of the cast be young girls, if only because it allows for more playfulness and humour. Lulu Wilson could pretty much be considered a scream queen by now after also taking the lead roll in ‘Ouija: Origin of Evil’ last year. The adults however aren’t anywhere near as satisfying. Stephanie Sigman tries her best as Sister Charlotte but the character is too annoyingly earnest for to give her anything to play with, Anthony LaPaglia looks like he’s wandered into the wrong film and can’t hide a boredom that borders on catatonia, and Miranda Otto has almost no reason for being there other than to look affected and wear a dumb mask that was probably stolen from that guy in ‘Boardwalk Empire’.

I suspect though that I’m entirely the wrong audience for this film. Sitting in the cinema, I heard countless people screaming, jumping and uncomfortably laughing the whole time, which was useful to drown out my running commentary on how much better it would be as a horror-comedy about Annabelle getting revenge on Linda for hitting her in the face with a ball. This isn’t a film for hardened horror fans, its for people who just want a good cheap scare with no consequence that that’ll go down well with their tasteless popcorn. Even as they were walking out, I could literally hear the audience forgetting about the film. ‘Annabelle: Creation’ is as unnecessary as its predecessor, another in the endless string of dumb, cheap and forgettable studio horror films dished out every year. And we still have another Conjuring spin-off of another pointless character, ‘The Nun’, to "enjoy" in the future (oh goody). Hopefully this is the end of the line for Annabelle, but it’s still pretty baffling that the minds behind this series seemed to think they could get this much traction out of such an ugly friggin’ doll.

RELEASE DATE: 10/08/2017
RUN TIME: 1h 49m
CAST: Stephanie Sigman
Talitha Bateman
Lulu Wilson
Philippa Ane Coulthard
Grace Fulton
Lou Lou Safran
Samara Lee
Tayler Buck
Anthony Lapaglia
Miranda Otto
DIRECTOR: David F. Sandberg
WRITER: Gary Dauberman
PRODUCERS: Peter Safran
James Wan
SCORE: Benjamin Wallfisch
Knives Out - The smart, star-packed whodunnit
TRENDINGWIN KNIVES OUTThe smart, star-packed whodunnit
Flack: Season 1 - Anna Paquin's darkly comedic drama
TRENDINGWIN FLACK: SEASON 1Anna Paquin's darkly comedic drama
The Expanse: Season 3 - The terrifying next phase
TRENDINGWIN THE EXPANSE: SEASON 3The terrifying next phase
Suzi Q - Celebrating a female rock icon
TRENDINGSUZI QCelebrating a female rock icon
Emu Runner - Another great win for Indigenous storytelling
TRENDINGEMU RUNNERAnother great win for Indigenous storytelling
Charlie's Angels - A new generation of Angels, another barrel of fun
TRENDINGCHARLIE'S ANGELSA new generation of Angels, another barrel of fun
God of the Piano - A tale that tickles the ivories
TRENDINGGOD OF THE PIANOA tale that tickles the ivories
Marriage Story - Simply extraordinary
Jewish International Film Festival 2019 - The reviews
Official Secrets - Exposing lies at a time of war
TRENDINGOFFICIAL SECRETSExposing lies at a time of war
30 years since 'Steel Magnolias' - The female-led films that made me
TRENDING30 YEARS SINCE 'STEEL MAGNOLIAS'The female-led films that made me
And Then We Danced - A passionate and remarkable classic in the making
TRENDINGAND THEN WE DANCEDA passionate and remarkable classic in the making
Children of the Sea - Sunk by a soggy script
Judy & Punch - A dark fairytale from a fresh Australian voice
TRENDINGJUDY & PUNCHA dark fairytale from a fresh Australian voice
NT Live: Fleabag - The birth of Phoebe Waller-Bridge's masterwork
TRENDINGNT LIVE: FLEABAGThe birth of Phoebe Waller-Bridge's masterwork
The Irishman - Kissing Scorsese’s ring (again)
TRENDINGTHE IRISHMANKissing Scorsese’s ring (again)
School's Out - The children know too much
TRENDINGSCHOOL'S OUTThe children know too much
Double Lover - Softcore pornography for cinephiles
TRENDINGDOUBLE LOVERSoftcore pornography for cinephiles
Fast & Furious: Hobbs & Shaw - Very furious, not so fast
TRENDINGFAST & FURIOUS: HOBBS & SHAWVery furious, not so fast
Claire Darling - A French film fail
© 2011 - 2019 midnightproductions
All rights reserved

Support SWITCH | Disclaimer | Contact Us